Appendix 6 · Practical Example

When $75 Million of Inventory Was Outside Effective Control

1. Executive Summary

A luxury retailer with $225 million in inventory faced recurring stock discrepancies exceeding $15 million and six-month reconciliations. Commissioned by the CFO, Gary Newbury established that uncontrolled merchandise movements and misplaced accountability were undermining reporting. He directed a redesigned stock-take and mobilized practical changes to recording and audit. During the first managed stock-take, the variances fell to $2 million and reconciliation time to three weeks.

2. Context and Need for Intervention

The $75 million revenue business depended on personal service and relationships with wealthy customers. Jewellery could leave a store on approval, sometimes for a special occasion, with the arrangement noted only in an employee’s notebook. Merchandise also went to suppliers for repairs without dependable documentation.

Across five locations, duplicate records and inadequately controlled movements made it difficult to distinguish genuine losses from goods held elsewhere or recording errors. Finance inherited discrepancies created in everyday operations. Lengthy reconciliations and recurring write-offs had become substitutes for effective control.

3. Establishing Reality

Gary followed the movement of merchandise rather than assuming the stock ledger described physical reality. Three weaknesses explained the recurring failures:

Transaction control: goods could be issued, transferred or returned without a reliable record of location and custody.

Operational accountability: employees handling merchandise were not consistently responsible for following through the movements they initiated.

Management discipline: delayed investigations and insufficient audit capability allowed discrepancies to accumulate.

The investigation identified $69 million of goods issued to customers on approval. Together with supplier movements and other misclassifications, $75 million required clarification. This was inventory outside reliable control, not simply merchandise known to be lost.

Category-specific investigations identified and eliminated control gaps associated with more than 60% of recurring stock losses.

When personal knowledge substitutes for operating control, the business becomes dependent on what individuals remember rather than what management can demonstrate.

4. Leadership and Decision Rights

The CFO sponsored the assignment. Gary directed the first physical stock-take and used the findings to challenge established practices.

His central decision was to place responsibility for accurate recording and follow-up with the people issuing and handling merchandise. Finance would reconcile the numbers; operating personnel would account for the movements.

Gary engaged retail, buying, stockroom and Finance teams to establish those responsibilities while preserving the personalized service customers expected.

5. Intervention and Operating Changes

Gary redesigned the stock-take, organized counting teams and controlled the count and audit arrangements, creating a credible starting position for reconciliation.

He introduced location and movement procedures, clearer variance classifications and focused investigations. A dedicated audit capability was established to provide daily checks between stock-takes.

The most telling change concerned goods issued on approval. Employees recorded who held each item, contacted customers, arranged returns where appropriate and formally recorded merchandise back into stock. A controlled On Appro ledger replaced reliance on notebooks and memory.

Following initial progress, Gary was commissioned to review merchandising, procurement and retail processes. His recommendations included separating creative design from inventory and merchandising decisions to strengthen commercial discipline.

6. Results and Transfer

Inventory variances fell from more than $15 million to $2 million, the lowest level reported in recent memory. Reconciliation reduced from more than 180 days to three weeks.

Management gained clearer visibility and accountability over $75 million of inadequately documented or classified inventory. Frontline responsibilities and a dedicated audit capability supported the changes.

Gary transferred the audited physical count to Finance and worked with client personnel and line management to establish ownership of the revised procedures. A further route towards one-week reconciliation was established.

Client testimonial

“Gary grasped our world quickly. His analysis was thorough, and his proposals were bold but grounded. He earned credibility with all departments. His work changed how we manage control across the board.”

Senior client executive, luxury goods retailer

7. What This Practical Example Demonstrates

Gary connected recurring financial discrepancies to the operating activities creating them. The intervention addressed the weaknesses at source instead of leaving Finance to reconstruct events months later.

Management information becomes reliable when the operating activities that produce it are reliably controlled.

Intervention Pathway: RADAR with targeted operational improvements.Delivery Model: Gary-led investigation and physical stock-take; assisted implementation under client executive accountability.

Gary Newbury
Senior Interim Executive — Reliable Performance Recovery & Operating Model Transformation