Appendix 11 · Practical Example

The Project Was Complete. The Operation Wasn’t Ready.

Restoring reliable performance when a critical outsourced operation failed and recovery depended on securing action through the provider’s leadership.

1. Executive Summary

A major organization outsourced a critical distribution operation, then saw fulfilment break down almost immediately. Incoming deliveries overwhelmed receiving capacity, orders could not be reliably picked and customer commitments were threatened ahead of an important trading period.

Gary Newbury identified the underlying constraints and drove recovery through the provider’s senior management and the client’s executive sponsorship. He combined immediate protection with corrective operating changes, overcoming resistance without direct command of the provider’s workforce.

Service returned to pre-transfer benchmarks within six weeks and productivity improved substantially. Gary subsequently redesigned a replacement facility, addressing longer-term operating requirements and significant property-related exposure.

2. Context and Need for Intervention

The outsourcing decision promised operating and property benefits. The first transfer phase had encountered difficulties when Gary replaced the departing Senior Project Manager during preparations for the final move.

His initial inspection exposed a fundamental concern: the facility had been organized around product categories rather than the work required to fulfil customer demand. He warned the executive sponsor that training alone would not make it work.

The breakdown followed within 24 hours of go-live. Picking locations had not been established, leaving replenishment movements without defined destinations. These were urgently addressed, the next morning, receiving capacity was overwhelmed as the inbound demand commenced.

The business faced an immediate recovery requirement. Continuing to push stock into the facility would deepen congestion while customers waited for orders it could not reliably fulfil.

3. Establishing Reality

Gary identified three connected weaknesses.

Insufficient capability assurance: the supplier’s experience had substituted for evidence that its actual facility and operating arrangements could meet the client’s requirements. Gary later learned that the facility differed from the one originally demonstrated to the client's team.

Design disconnected from demand: fast-moving products had insufficient accessible picking capacity. Pickers and replenishment equipment obstructed one another in very long narrow aisles, creating queues and repeated shortages at picking locations.

Incomplete operating readiness: missing procedures and transaction stages obscured the physical position of inventory. Stock could appear available at its final destination while still passing through intermediate transfer points.

These weaknesses reinforced one another. Congestion delayed replenishment, inaccurate visibility released orders prematurely, and employees encountered empty picking positions despite recorded availability.

The operation needed its constraints removed, rather than more effort applied around them.

4. Leadership and Decision Rights

Gary reported to the client’s executive sponsor, who held COO and CFO responsibilities. His task was to drive recovery while the provider retained management of its workforce and facility.

The contract permitted temporary operational direction by the client. Gary proposed exercising that provision and offered to take control. The sponsor chose not to activate it.

Gary therefore had to secure corrective action through the provider’s leadership. He attended operating meetings, demonstrated the constraints directly and challenged explanations that did not fit the evidence.

Where managers resisted changes, including physical alterations, he developed the solution, established its operational necessity and pressed for implementation through senior management and client sponsorship.

The difficulty was not simply diagnosing failure. It was turning that diagnosis into urgent action across organizational boundaries while service continued deteriorating.

5. Intervention and Operating Changes

Gary escalated the need to stop or divert inbound deliveries. Stock was redirected to an existing operation that could support continuing fulfilment and supply the troubled facility, creating breathing space for recovery.

He redesigned the pick path and inventory positioning around demand, making faster-moving products more accessible and allocating additional picking slots where required to significantly reduced nil picks. This reduced replenishment pressure and competition for aisle access.

He also secured removal of selected racking and associated infrastructure changes to create a wide-aisle area for intensive smaller-item picking.

Working with an assigned client IT project manager, Gary reconstructed missing procedures and corrected transaction stages at intermediate transfer points. System records could then distinguish a completed handoff from arrival at the final location.

The changes were implemented during his involvement. He remained through the important trading period and product-range transition as the operation stabilized.

A subsequent assignment addressed a pressing property deadline. The temporary location’s lease extension was limited, with substantial potential penalties for missing the exit date. Gary materially revised the proposed replacement facility’s layout, flows and operating processes and secured design approval. Subsequent implementation and migration remained client-led.

6. Results and Transfer

Service began recovering towards the end of the second week and returned to pre-transfer fulfilment benchmarks within six weeks.

The implemented changes reduced congestion, increased picking capacity and strengthened the connection between physical inventory movements and system records. Productivity improved substantially, and the provider’s teams operated the revised arrangements through the important trading period.

The approved replacement design established a route to a more suitable long-term operation. A combined value opportunity exceeding $10 million was projected, principally from avoiding property-related penalties alongside productivity benefits. The client and provider retained responsibility for the subsequent migration.

Client testimonial

“Gary stepped in during the height of crisis and brought immediate clarity. Within hours, he had exposed fundamental flaws in the logistics setup and got everyone focused on recovery. His leadership didn’t just get us back on track, it set the foundation for a long-term operational solution. A transformational intervention at a critical moment.”

Client Executive Sponsor, COO and CFO

7. What This Practical Example Demonstrates

Completing an outsourced transfer does not establish that the resulting operation can perform.

Gary connected an immediate service meltdown to weaknesses in capability assurance, operating design and implementation readiness. He then secured the detailed corrections needed to restore control.

Working through a third party made leadership more demanding. Recovery required compelling evidence, practical solutions, executive sponsorship, and persistent pressure for implementation.

The leadership question: When a critical provider fails, who will establish what must change and ensure that it happens?

Intervention Pathway: Operational recovery through a third-party provider, followed by a related replacement-facility design assignment.

Delivery Model: Gary-led recovery direction, investigation and corrective design under client executive sponsorship; implementation through the provider’s management and client-led subsequent migration.

Gary Newbury
Senior Interim Executive — Reliable Performance Recovery & Operating Model Transformation